15 Comments
May 4, 2023Liked by John Ganz

Idpol is result not cause--is actually an ad hoc working class politics and basically the only one we've got right now--is one of those insights so basic and fundamental it's genuinely surprising how little representation it gets in the wider discourse.

Expand full comment

Absolutely here for the TNR villain cameo.

Expand full comment

I don't think this is giving nearly enough credit to the need for both racial and gender based progress and reform *within the labor movement.* It's not just a matter of liberal identitarian fracturing that leads to racial minorities and women to form and turn to organizations that promote their interests, but a straightforward material complaint: their interests weren't/aren't represented by Left-labor organizations and politics that are inevitably imbued with the racism and misogyny of the broader culture. To say that they shouldn't do so - that it's a fracturing that gives away the game to the forces of conservatism and resentment - comes pretty close to buying in to the broader social hierarchies proposed by those forces.

Expand full comment